Writers on the Range: The last thing we need is a gold mine


By Marcie Carter

PREVIEW Columnist

As a citizen of the Nez Perce, or Nimíipuu, which means the People, I look at gold mining as a symbol of broken promises. 

In 1855, when my ancestors entered into a treaty with the United States, we ceded millions of acres in what eventually became Idaho, Oregon and Washington. In exchange, we reserved an exclusive homeland and rights to fish, hunt, gather and pasture throughout our vast aboriginal territory. 

Then, in 1860, gold was discovered and thousands of prospectors flooded across our borders in violation of the treaty, damaging our sacred places and natural resources and causing unspeakable injury to our people.

The United States failed to uphold the terms of the 1855 treaty and instead forced the Nez Perce to enter into a new treaty in 1863. Known by us as the “steal treaty,” it reduced the size of our homeland by 90 percent and allowed miners and other non-Indians to remain on lands they had illegally occupied. 

When several Nez Perce bands led by Chief Joseph demanded that the United States uphold the promises it had made in the 1855 treaty and refused to move to the new reservation, the federal government resorted to military force, prompting the Nez Perce War of 1877.

A century and a half later, the promise of gold once again threatens our homeland and way of life. 

The Stibnite Gold Project is proposed by a Canadian company that recently moved to Idaho. The mine site is located within Nez Perce ceded territory in the headwaters of the South Fork Salmon River, a watershed that once was home to one of the largest Chinook salmon runs in the Columbia River Basin. We have treaty-reserved rights in this culturally significant area and have worked over the years to restore fish habitat that benefits everyone, an effort that cost millions of dollars. 

The Stibnite Gold Project would be one of the largest gold mines in the country. The company aims to extract between 4 million and 5 million ounces of gold from three open pit mines during the estimated 21- to 28-year life of the project. 

Despite the company’s claim that it will “restore the site” that is already heavily polluted by a legacy of mining, the proposal to expand the area and mine it again will add hundreds of millions of tons of additional mining waste and tailings. The proposal will also require storage of the new toxic waste, plus active water treatment long after the company is done mining the site.

The company’s mining would also restrict or prohibit treaty-reserved access for more than two decades or even longer. It would also destroy critical habitat for endangered Chinook salmon and bull trout, and other resources cherished by the Nez Perce and all Idahoans.

The Nez Perce doubt that the company will stick around if the mine is permitted by the federal government. The company is now majority-owned by a New York-based corporation that recently replaced most of the mining company’s governing board. 

The company might opt to sell its shares for a huge profit and then exit the scene. A new corporation could then step in to extract gold, leaving behind a new legacy of toxic contamination and resource destruction that will plague our communities for generations to come. 

We know all too well the pattern of exploit and abandon. Corporations don’t keep their promises and federal mining laws offer little or no accountability. We want this permit to mine gold denied.

The United States, as a signatory to the 1855 treaty and trustee to the tribe, has a responsibility to protect and honor our treaty rights and resources. These treaty obligations, which predate the 1872 General Mining Law, are rooted in the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution and represent the solemn word of the United States. 

For us, the Nimíipuu, the value of the land, fish, wildlife and other natural resources will always be worth more than gold. Chief Joseph left us with these words that we will never forget: “It makes my heart sick when I remember all the good words and the broken promises.” 

The United States must not turn a blind eye to the Stibnite Gold Project. We ask that this country honor Nez Perce treaty rights and protect the lands and resources important to all the people of Idaho.

Marcie Carter is a citizen of the Nez Perce Tribe and a contributor to Writers on the Range, writersontherange.org, a nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about the West.