On Monday, Nov. 16, the Pagosa Area Water and Sanitation District (PAWSD) Board of Directors approved a settlement agreement for the district’s litigation with the San Juan Water Conservancy District (SJWCD) with two modifications at its Nov. 16 meeting, following a lengthy and contentious debate.
The litigation between the districts focuses on whether or not PAWSD has the right to sell the Running Iron Ranch — which is jointly owned by the two districts and where the SJWCD aims to build a reservoir — without the consent of the SJWCD.
The SJWCD argued that this violated the terms of a previous three-way agreement between PAWSD, the SJWCD and the Colorado Water Conservation Board (CWCB) governing the management of the ranch.
The lawsuit started in December 2024 when the SJWCD refused to consent to PAWSD’s potential plans to sell the property to Zipper Valley Ranch, represented by Trey Fricke, and PAWSD sued in an attempt to clarify whether the three-way agreement allowed it to sell the ranch without the SJWCD’s consent and to argue that it did.
The districts began negotiations over a settlement agreement in March 2026, following a variety of filings and summary judgment on a portion of the case by District Court Judge Justin Fay.
The agreement, without the modifications, was previously approved and signed by the SJWCD on Nov. 6, after having been sent to the district by PAWSD.
The discussion on Nov. 16 opened with a debate about whether the board should go into executive session to discuss the settlement and hear from its attorney or not, with PAWSD board members Bill Hudson and Glenn Walsh opposing the executive session on the basis of public transparency.
PAWSD legal counsel Marcus Lock of Law of the Rockies highlighted that entering an executive session would require support from two-thirds of the board, which would not be possible with Walsh and Hudson opposing the session, and stated that he believed most of the issues before the district in terms of whether to sign the agreement were appropriate for public discussion.
After the board decided to not enter executive session, Walsh explained that he had continued to communicate with Zipper Valley following its 2024 purchase proposal and that it was willing to make an offer to purchase the ranch at a price that would pay off PAWSD’s approximately $10.4 million in debt obligations on the property and would give the district a permanent conservation easement for a reservoir up to 3,000 acre feet, without any additional timelines or conditions, which had been a feature of the previous Zipper Valley proposal.
Walsh added that he would favor not signing the settlement agreement and returning to court to litigate for PAWSD to be able to sell the property to Zipper Valley under the terms of the new offer.
Hudson commented that he would also support doing this and that litigation would potentially cost $100,000, in his opinion.
“To me, going back to court is a bargain,” Hudson said. “This agreement we’re looking at is not a bargain. It’s kicking the can down the road for a year. Right now, we have an excellent proposal for our customers and we just need to push forward with the very best offer we have, and this agreement with [the SJWCD] is not the very best offer we have.”
PAWSD board members Bruce Jones, Alex Boehmer and board chairman Gene Tautges asked questions about this offer and expressed concerns about its last-minute nature and the lack of clear terms or a formal offer before the board.
Tautges commented that he believed approving the settlement would be ideal since it would give PAWSD a mechanism to ensure that the SJWCD progresses in its obligations, including selling a portion of the ranch and renegotiating the terms of certain loan agreements connected to the ranch with the CWCB, and would strengthen a future case by PAWSD if the SJWCD fails to make appropriate progress and complete the sale, renegotiations and other conditions by the end of 2027, as required by the settlement.
Boehmer stated that it would be difficult for him to make a decision on the Zipper Valley offer at the meeting since he had not had time to review it and that he was concerned that Zipper Valley intentionally provided a more favorable agreement at the last minute when the settlement was nearly approved.
He also expressed frustration with the “last-minute surprises” being presented to the board.
Lock commented that PAWSD would be unlikely to be able to sell the ranch currently without a court order and the litigation to obtain such an order would be unpredictable and would not necessarily cost the $100,000 that some board members had suggested.
He also noted that a previous three-way agreement requires the SJWCD and PAWSD to cooperate on filing diligence applications for water rights associated with the property, which the districts are currently in the process of doing and which Zipper Valley has filed to oppose.
The board then discussed if it could continue to negotiate with Zipper Valley while the settlement agreement is in place and the SJWCD is working on fulfilling its terms.
Walsh also raised concerns about a term in the settlement agreement which states that PAWSD would have 24 hours to review and approve a purchase offer for a portion of the property that the SJWCD wished to pursue, commenting that this was too short of a time to allow for an appropriate review.
Fricke then spoke to the board, commenting in response to Boehmer’s concerns that he had not intended to provide an offer at the last minute and that he had wanted to wait until the “dust settled” regarding the settlement agreement negotiations before presenting another offer, although he had continued conversations with Walsh, Hudson and occasionally other PAWSD board members.
He added that he had concerns that the settlement agreement did not have enough teeth and would be ineffective in ensuring that the SJWCD makes progress or in giving PAWSD options if the SJWCD fails to do so.
In response to a question from Walsh about if he would be willing to continue working with PAWSD over the approximately one-year term of the settlement agreement and then potentially purchase the property afterwards if the SJWCD fails to move forward, Fricke said, “I think it’s a ridiculous proposition and probably not,” although he added later that he would not necessarily say that he would not be available in a year, but would not commit to it.
Following more discussion, the board voted on a motion by Walsh to move forward with the Zipper Valley Ranch offer and reenter litigation, which failed 3-2, with Hudson and Walsh voting in favor and Boehmer, Jones and Tautges voting against.
Hudson then moved to table the settlement agreement and to ask the SJWCD to obtain and present a letter from the CWCB that it is “interested” in the arrangement and a framework for how the SJWCD would pay off the loan obligations it would be assuming under the settlement to PAWSD before March 1, 2027. If the SJWCD did this, then Hudson stated that PAWSD could sign the agreement.
The board then discussed this concept, with Lock raising concerns that if the board does not like the current settlement agreement, as Hudson stated he did not, then it should likely continue to use the established negotiation process to alter the agreement and not pursue a different approach.
He added, following more discussion, that accepting Hudson’s motion would not be legally advised.
Walsh commented that he would want the 24-hour approval provision in the settlement changed to a four- or five-day window and that he would want language about how PAWSD would refuse to provide any private customer data to the SJWCD added to the agreement.
The board then extensively discussed these additions and their potential impact on the SJWCD’s willingness to agree to the settlement, which board members broadly indicated they believed would not compromise it.
Tautges also made a motion to approve the settlement as approved by the SJWCD, which died for lack of a second, and Jones and Walsh, among others, expressed doubts that the SJWCD would be able to make any progress on completing the settlement agreement’s objectives.
However, following these discussions and others, the board voted to approve the agreement with the changes of requiring a six-day window for the PAWSD to review purchase offers for a portion of the property submitted to it by the SJWCD and additional language concerning how PAWSD would not provide the SJWCD with private customer data by a 4-1 vote, with Hudson in opposition.
Lock indicated that he would submit the revised agreement to the SJWCD for its future consideration.
josh@pagosasun.com