Tent caterpillars can be a severe nuisance in southwestern Colorado. Spring outbreaks result in masses of tents in trees, defoliation of deciduous trees, and ample frustration for the landowner trying to control the masses of larvae.
Their wriggling tents are where the larvae are found. Different tent caterpillars will feed on various species of trees with fruit trees, aspen, mountain mahogany, oak, ash, and cottonwood used as hosts. Tent caterpillars feed and establish their silky tents in the crotches of trees and shrubs in late spring. During heavy infestations, the tent caterpillars will migrate and feed on a variety of other plants.
Several kinds of caterpillars feed in groups or colonies on trees and shrubs and produce a silken shelter or tent. Most common in spring are various types of tent caterpillars (Malacosoma species). During summer, large loose tents produced by fall webworm (Hyphantria cunea) are seen on the branches of cottonwoods, chokecherry, and many other plants. Occasionally, early spring outbreaks of caterpillars of the tiger moth (Lophocampa species) attract attention.
Four species of tent caterpillars occur in Colorado. The western tent caterpillar (M. californicum) most often is seen infesting aspen and mountain-mahogany during May and early June. Many other plants, particularly fruit trees, may also be infested. The western tent caterpillar is the most common and damaging tent caterpillar, sometimes producing widespread outbreaks that have killed large areas of aspen.
In stands of gambel oak, the sonoran tent caterpillar (M. tigris) occurs and the M. incurvatum discoloratum can be found feeding on cottonwoods and related trees during April and early May in the Tri River area of western Colorado. In northeastern Colorado, the eastern tent caterpillar (M. americanum) can occasionally be found on fruit trees.
These tent caterpillars spend the winter in egg masses glued to twigs of the host plant. Prior to winter, the insects transform to caterpillars and emerge from the eggs shortly after bud break. The newly emerged caterpillars move to crotches of branches and begin to produce a mass of dense silk.
This silken tent is used by the developing insects for rest and shelter during the day. They also molt (shed their skins) while on the silk mats. Most often the caterpillars leave the silk shelter to feed at night, returning by daylight, although they sometimes feed during daylight hours as well. The tent is gradually enlarged as the caterpillars grow.
The caterpillars become full grown in late spring. Most wander from the area of the tent and spin a white cocoon of silk, within which they pupate. The adult moths, which are light brown with faint light wavy bands on the wings emerge about two weeks later. The moths mate and the females then lay a single egg mass. Tent caterpillars produce only one generation per year.
The most common and damaging tent caterpillar found in urban areas is the forest tent caterpillar, M. disstria. Although its life history is similar to other tent caterpillars, the forest tent caterpillar does not produce a permanent tent as do the other species. Instead, they make light mats of silk on trunks and branches that are used as temporary resting areas during the day. Forest tent caterpillars feed on a wide variety of plants, including aspen, ash and various fruit trees. Occasionally, they produce outbreaks that can damage plants.
Fall webworm is the most common tent caterpillar observed during midsummer. It is found on a many different plants, although chokecherry and cottonwood are the most common hosts. Winter is spent as a pupa, loosely buried under protective debris in the vicinity of previously infested trees. The adults, a nearly pure white moth, emerge in June and July, mate and lay eggs in masses on the leaves of trees and shrubs. Eggs hatch shortly afterwards. The young caterpillars feed as a group, covering the few leaves on which they feed. As they get older, fall webworms progressively cover larger areas of the plant with loose silk, and generally feed within the loose tent that they produce. When full grown, the caterpillars disperse and sometimes create a nuisance as they crawl over fences and sides of homes.
There is only one generation of fall webworm known to occur in Colorado, although two or more generations are produced in parts of Kansas, Oklahoma, Texas and other nearby states.
Caterpillars of tiger moths (L. ingens, L. argentata) make a dense mat of silk on the terminal growth of ponderosa pine, lodgepole pine, pinyon, Douglas-fir, white fir and juniper. They are one of the few caterpillars that continue to feed and develop during winter. They produce and occupy tents through early spring. By June, they complete their development and pupate. The adult moths emerge and fly during July and August, laying masses of eggs that hatch before fall.
Historically, outbreaks of tiger moths occur most commonly in the Black Forest area near Colorado Springs and in West Slope pinyon-juniper stands. Top-kill of damaged trees commonly results from these injuries.
Minor tent-producing insects
A few other insects are found in Colorado and produce silken tents. Uglynest caterpillars (Archips cerasivornana) can be found on chokecherry, where they produce a messy nest of silk mixed with bits of leaves and insect frass. Outbreaks of the rabbitbrush webbing moth (Synnoma lynsyrana) occasionally damage rabbitbrush. An uncommon group of sawflies, known as web-spinning sawflies, also produce mats of silk on spruce, pines or plum.
Many natural enemies attack all of the tent-making caterpillars. Birds, predaceous bugs and various hunting wasps prey on the caterpillars. Tachinid flies and parasitic wasps are important parasites. Tent caterpillars also are susceptible to a virus disease that can devastate populations. Because of these biological controls, serious outbreaks rarely last more than a single season. An exception is found in some communities where fall webworm is an annual problem. One reason for these sustained outbreaks may be the loss of biological controls due to aerial mosquito spraying.
The microbial insecticide Bacillus thuringiensis (Dipel, Thuricide, etc.) can be an effective and selective control of all the tent-making caterpillars. However, to control fall webworm, Bt must be eaten by the insect. Therefore, it must be applied before the colony covers all of the leaves.
Several contact insecticides also are effective for tent-making caterpillars. Sevin (carbaryl) has long been available. More recently, various pyrethroids such as permethrin, cyfluthrin and esfenvalerate are available for homeowner application and are highly effective. Spinosad, a naturally-derived product (sold as Conserve to commercial applicators) is very selective in its effects of species other than caterpillars.
If accessible, tents may also be pulled out and removed. More severe measures, such as pruning or burning, are not recommended because they can cause more injury than the insects.
Often, there is no need to control these insects. This is particularly true for fall webworm, which feeds late in the season. Such late season injuries can be well tolerated by plants. Control normally is warranted only where there are sustained, high levels of defoliation over several years.
Information provided by W.S. Cranshaw, Colorado State University Extension entomologist and professor, bioagricultural sciences and pest management.
May 18 — 4-H Clover Buds, 1:45 p.m.
May 18 — 4-H Dog Agility, 3 p.m.
May 18 — 4-H Rabbit Project, 4 p.m.
May 21 — Back to Basic Food Prep-Pickling/Freezing, 1 p.m.
May 21 — Back Country Horseman, 5:30 p.m.
May 21 — Back to Basic Food Prep–Pickling/Freezing, 6 p.m.
May 22 — 4-H Clothing Construction, 3:45 p.m.
May 23 — 4-H Sports Fishing, 4 p.m.
May 23 — Archuleta County Fair Board meeting, 6 p.m.
Check out our webpage at www.archuleta.colostate.edu for calendar events and information.